Pandora: Good Enough for Miserly Bastards

I had a chance to meet Tom Conrad from Pandora last week at the dinner after Blog Business Summit, and then again at Bar Camp. Pandora’s service basically allows you to generate a personal set of “stations” based on a favorite song or artist – their backend does the rest!

Now, hear me as I speak with the authority that only a miserly cheap bastard can muster: this is actually something I would pay for.

Like any self-respecting music aficionado, I have a pretty big collection of music. But that amount of music has an unfortunate side effect – the more music you have, the less you actually listen to new music. Pandora solves this, feeding you a constant stream of only the good stuff. I’ve been listening to it the last three evenings, and it’s been a “set and forget” experience. Wow.

The part that’s really interesting about this service is that it’s a big of a legal hack – because of the way webcasting royalties work it costs Pandora almost nothing to provide the music itself (the cost is really in the bandwidth and the tech to provide accurate recommendations). The service, currently in invitation-only “preview”, is expected to be in the “couple bucks a month” price range. Totally acceptable.

The one thing I would like to see Pandora do with its technology is extend it to the music I already own. Why? Well, because of the aforementioned webcasting hack, there are certain restrictions on what Pandora can offer. It can’t, for example, just serve you the exact song you want – music on demand is verboten (which makes sense, given that webcasting rules are meant to be analogous to the rules for radio). Also, when streaming music to your machine, you can’t see what song is next, or play the previous song. A bit annoying. But imagine if you could had a Pandora plugin for iTunes that allowed you to autocreate playlists of stuff you owned that were similar/matched. You do this yourself currently, but what if Pandora could do it for you, and allow you to effectively take their service with you? Imagine how much music you currently own that you don’t listen to, simply because you inevitably end up playing the same stuff again and again.

Bottom line: Pandora is awesome – check it out. Uh, I mean, check it out when there’s a public beta. If you’re interested in additional details about Pandora, you might also want to check out this review at TechCrunch.

Anti-Karaoke

On occasion I pretend to be a guitarist. Honing my solo improvisational skills is a difficult task, especially given that half the time I’m practicing on my own without the benefit of a band to provide the backing track. Practicing scales or jamming over top of CDs is one approach, but there’s only so much you can do. Sometimes I use Transcribe! to loop sections of CDs without lead guitar, but that can get really repetitive and limit the usefulness of the exercise.

Recently, it occurred to me that what I really want is the equivalent of karaoke tracks, but for guitar. Imagine if you could buy electronic versions of a song with one of the instruments removed from the track. Guitarists could mute the guitar track; drummers could mute the drum track; bass players could mute the bass track. Musicians could go to a web site, pick which instrument they wanted removed from the master recording, and purchase and download the result in GarageBand format.

Sounds like a nice way for the record industry to pick up another bunch of cash from its massive back catalog. Add in performance rights and high-end versions of the tracks that allow the performer to tweak the mix themselves to create a “professional” version for working solo musicians. Of course, longer term, I expect artists will shortcut this whole process and release their source tracks for free directly to the public as a way of encouraging remixes (just like Trent Reznor did with his recent album).

Take it one step further, and you could totally transform the idea of karaoke clubs. Instead of just having karaoke where people get up and sing, you could have karaoke nights where individual musicians could play without needing to assemble a whole band.